Here is a list of advantages of having a standardized ELL curriculum
  • According to Sleeter, multicultural curriculum has as its purpose social improvement and equitable conditions for learning that can close achievement gaps. (Sleeter)
 
  • Setting national standards allows for equal pupil opportunity. All pupils are compared to the same standards. If there are no common standards and every teacher sets his or her own standards, schools’ demands on their pupils will be different. Since there is nothing for schools to compare with, both instruction and assessment cannot be consistent.

  • If national standards are set, it is clear what pupils should know at different levels of their education. Exams given by the state can measure pupil progress towards attaining the standards. Pupils who are not achieving the standards can be provided with early, effective assistance. 

  • Setting standards is an important and effective learning tool because they express clear expectations of what all pupils should know and be able to do with the language. They can be helpful to different populations, such as the state, districts and schools, teachers, pupils and parents. The following describes how setting standards can help these different populations (Harris & Carr, 1996).

  • Standards in and of themselves are meaningless. What counts are the steps that educators and others take to help pupils reach them. (Fiske, 1998). If the Ministry of Education, Culture and Sport decides to embark on the implication of standards-based education, there are different areas that they will need to be addressed regarding pupils, teachers, assessment and the setting of standards.

  • The state. For the state, standards are a common reference tool and provide a defined framework for national testing. 

  • Districts and schools. For districts and schools, standards provide a focus for developing new ways to organize curriculum content, instructional programs and assessment plans.

  • Teachers. Standards help teachers design curriculum, instruction and assessment on the basis of what it is important to learn. They also enable teachers to make expectations clear to pupils, which improves their learning.

  • Pupils. For pupils, standards set clear performance expectations, helping them understand what they need to do in order to meet the standards.

  • Parents. Since standards communicate shared expectations for learning, they allow parents to know how their children are progressing in their education.
eslteacher
1/28/2014 02:00:58 am

Sleeter argues “even when much of the curriculum is prescribed for teachers, they need to be able to decide on material most worth teaching. They also need to create and make use of spaces in that curriculum in which students can make connections with prior knowledge and experience.” This questions the core purpose of having the standardized curriculum in diverse learning contexts. What would be the point of having the standardized prescribed curriculum, when it is the teachers who choose what and how to teach?

Reply
ell345
1/28/2014 02:07:13 am

“Each general learning outcome includes specific learning outcomes that students are to achieve by the end of each grade. Specific outcomes are categorized under headings within each of the five general outcomes. The specific learning outcomes state the knowledge, skills, and attitudes that students are expected to demonstrate at the end of each grade. They are relevant for all students in a variety of learning environments and are cumulative across the grades. Students are expected to demonstrate the specific learning outcomes for their current grade while building on and maintaining their ability to demonstrate the specific learning outcomes for previous grades.”

If you take a look at the Curriculum Framework phrased by NWCP, their curriculum is relevant to “students in a variety of learning environments,” including ELL students. In other words, in order for ELL students’ language skills should meet up with ELA curriculum in order for them to meet up with class expectations in regular classes. This is an unfair and inconsiderate expectation to have against ELL students who came overseas to learn the language.

Reply
MyKidisinESL
1/28/2014 02:19:11 am

As a parent, I would love to see standardized curriculum in ESL classes

Reply



Leave a Reply.

      Survey

    Archives

    January 2014

    Categories

    All